Joseph Phelps Syrah Napa Valley 2012

90-92 points Antonio Galloni (Vinous): “Dark red cherry, plum, spice, mocha and new leather notes flesh out in the 2012 Syrah, a wine distinguished by its aromatic complexity and nuance. A beautifully detailed wine, the 2012 is full of personality and character. Layers of fruit build to the rich, textured finish. There is plenty of potential in this plush, full-bodied Syrah. As always, the straight Syrah is a bit chunkier than the Hyde bottling, but that is more of an observation than a critique. The 2012 was done with 25% whole clusters and a dash (6-7%) of Viognier. Drink: 2014-2022. (Nov 2013)”

91 points Wine Spectator: “Framed by creamy, toasty espresso bean–scented oak, the syrupy core of black cherry, blackberry and boysenberry flavors fold together nicely, giving it a sense of completeness, finishing with a pretty fruit aftertaste. 900 cases made. (12/31/04)”